Giving Advice: “You need to eat healthier to improve your chances of getting pregnant.”

"I'll Have What She's Having"—Meg Ryan by Stuart© Live the you Desire

“I’ll Have What She’s Having”—Meg Ryan
by Mimi Stuart © Live the you Desire


Often the best way to give advice to loved ones is to send them an article that gives the advice that you’d like to give, but it comes from an expert with appropriate back-up research. You simply say, “I thought you’d find this article worthwhile. I found it very interesting.”

You have to be tactful when giving forthright advice to people who have not asked for your advice. For example, if you recommend to someone who is having trouble getting pregnant that she stop eating junk food, she may be offended. She will probably view you as being judgmental and intrusive rather than loving and concerned. She may also avoid you in the future not wanting to feel judged whenever she drinks a soft drink in front of you. Moreover, she’s unlikely to take your advice seriously because you are not a nutritionist or a fertility doctor.

So instead you might send her an email with one or two articles attached — not twenty-five — and a note saying, “I thought you might find this new research about fertility helpful and interesting.” You will sound less superior and disapproving. The article will have more authority and be more likely to get her attention.

If she resists the information, it may be best to drop it. While it is loving to try to help or enlighten people, once they are informed, it is best to allow them to make their own choices.

by Alison Poulsen, PhD

Read “Giving Advice: ‘She never listens to me.’”

Read “Motivating Change: ‘I can’t stop criticizing my partner.’”

Giving Advice: “She never listens to me.”

"Snowflakes" by Mimi Stuart
Live the Life you Desire

Advice is like snow; the softer it falls, the longer it dwells upon, and the deeper it sinks into the mind.

~Samuel Taylor Coleridge

1. Select an appropriate time and private setting to talk.

2. Ask the person whether she would like some advice or if you could tell her a story that might have some bearing on the situation.

3. Find out the person’s state of mind or point of view to make sure your advice is appropriate.

4. Remember that no one knows for sure what is best for another person. Telling a personal story has a greater effect than if you tell someone you know what’s best for her.

5. Frame your advice as a positive suggestion rather than negative criticism.

6. Don’t repeat advice. Pushiness has the opposite effect; it builds resistance.

7. Respect the other person’s autonomy. Let her decide whether or not to take your advice.

The true secret of giving advice is, after you have honestly given it, to be perfectly indifferent whether it is taken or not, and never persist in trying to set people right.

~Hannah Whitall Smith

by Alison Poulsen, PhD

Read “You never listen!”

Read “Conversation and Active Listening: ‘It seems like I do all the talking.’”